On this page
In a big contest the popular players decide whether you have a bad day. The unpopular ones decide whether you have a great one. That second group has a name, differentials, and most teams choose them badly: too many, too random, or in place of the wrong player. Here is a way to choose them on purpose.
What counts as a differential
A differential is a player picked by a small share of the teams in your contest. Many players use a rough line of 10% to 15%. If the platform shows a “selected by” figure for each player, use it. If it does not, estimate: last match’s top scorers, the biggest names and anyone the broadcasters talked about all week will be heavily owned.
Low ownership alone is not enough. Plenty of players are unpopular because they are unlikely to score. A differential worth picking is unpopular and has a job that can produce a big score today.
The arithmetic of ownership
Imagine 10,000 teams. A star opener is in 7,000 of them. A quieter opener from the other side is in 800.
| He scores 70 and you have him | You gain ground on |
|---|---|
| The star opener | The 3,000 teams without him |
| The quiet opener | The 9,200 teams without him |
The same 70 is worth three times as much field position when it comes from the quiet player. The catch is the other half of the sum: when the star scores and you left him out to make room, 7,000 teams move past you. That is why differentials go in next to the stars, not instead of them.
Add, do not fade
There are two ways to be different. To fade is to leave out a heavily owned player and hope he fails. To add is to keep the obvious core and be different in the remaining slots. Fading a star is a bet against a good player in a good slot, and it loses more often than it wins. Adding costs little: the eighth to eleventh players in most teams are weak picks anyway, so replacing them with differentials gives up almost nothing.
Four places differentials hide
- The underdog’s top order. Openers bat whatever the result, yet the crowd fills its batting slots from the favourite.
- Bowlers with fixed overs on unfashionable sides. Someone bowls the last two overs for the weaker team, and those overs produce wickets.
- Players whose role has just changed. A batter promoted to number three, or a seamer newly handed the new ball, is still picked on his old role.
- Good players after two failures. Ownership follows the last scorecard. A proven opener who made 4 and 9 is the same player at a fraction of the popularity.
What is not a differential
- A number eight who does not bowl. He is unpopular for good reason.
- A squad player who may not make the eleven.
- A big name out of position: low in the order, or bowling only an over or two.
- Anyone chosen because nobody else will have him, with no other reason.
How many to carry
| Contest | Differentials | Captain |
|---|---|---|
| Head-to-head, or up to ten teams | None, or one | The most involved player, however popular |
| A few hundred teams | One or two | A popular captain with a less popular vice-captain |
| Mega contest | Two or three | Consider a differential as captain or vice-captain |
These are working rules, not laws. The principle underneath is that the larger the field and the steeper the prizes, the more a team has to differ to reach the places that pay. The reasoning is on the small contests and mega contests page.
A worked choice
A T20 on a flat pitch. Team A are favourites and will supply most of everyone’s core. You have eight players settled and three slots left. The candidates:
- Team B’s second opener. He faces the new ball and is little picked because his partner is the star. Take him.
- Team B’s death bowler. He bowls the eighteenth and twentieth overs, when Team A will be swinging. Take him.
- Team A’s number seven, a famous hitter who has faced six balls a game this series. Leave him. The name is big; the opportunity is not.
- Team A’s third seamer. He bowls in the middle overs, where a flat pitch gives him nothing. Leave him, and use the last slot on a reliable pick.
Two differentials, both from the side the crowd is ignoring, both with guaranteed work. If Team B make a game of it, this team climbs. If they do not, the core of eight still scores.
The thirty-second test
- Is he in the announced eleven?
- Does he bat in the top four, or bowl at least three overs in a T20?
- Do today’s conditions suit his type?
- Would I still be content with the pick if he scored ten? If not, it is a gamble, not a differential.
Differentials are the last step of building a team, not the first. Start with building a balanced eleven, then use the final slots to be different on purpose.
